He gave me something that I couldn't believe in He gave me something made me chide, chide, chide He gave me something that I could not believe in He put a hello and goodbye, bye, bye It wasn't hard to make him understand me He turned my pages like a pirouette He made me feel just like a farmer's daughter Who couldn't wait to get her boots on wet I know you're afraid of grieving And I'll give you my open heart You'll own keys to every room inside my haunted house Of magic in the dark, dark, dark He wrapped his arms around me like a blanket He spun a web around me like a spell He flung an anchor through my ship and sank it I never knew that I could drown so well I know you're afraid of grieving And I'll give you my open heart You'll own keys to every room inside my haunted house Of magic in the dark, dark, dark My haunted house of magic in the dark, dark, dark I wanna be where you can't see, you can't feel Words in the way, nothing can say what kisses can steal I wanna be where you can't see, you can't feel Words in the way, nothing can say what kisses can steal I know you're afraid of grieving And I'll give you my open heart You'll own keys to every room inside my haunted house Of magic in the dark, dark, dark My haunted house of magic in the dark, dark, dark I know you're afraid of grieving And I'll give you my open heart You'll own keys to every room, keys to every room inside the dark, dark, dark You gave me something that I couldn't believe in You gave me something that made me try, try, try You gave me something that I couldn't believe in You gave me something that made me try, try, try I know you're afraid of grieving And I'll give you my own Try, try, try Try, try, try